Forgot password Extend Verify Contact

2877 McSherry Lane
559 - Cataract Road Thorold L0S 1E6

$1,799,900
Residential Freehold beds: 3+1 baths: 3.0

Main Photo: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 1: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 2: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 3: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 4: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 5: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 6: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 7: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 8: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 9: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 10: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 11: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 12: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 13: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 14: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 15: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 16: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 17: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 18: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 19: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 20: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 21: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 22: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 23: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 24: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 25: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 26: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 27: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 28: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 29: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 30: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 31: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 32: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 33: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 34: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 35: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 36: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 37: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 38: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 39: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 40: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 41: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 42: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 43: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 44: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 45: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 46: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 47: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 48: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 49: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Photo 50: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
Status:
Active
Prop. Type:
Residential Freehold
MLS® Num:
X13438342
Bedrooms:
3+1
Bathrooms:
3
A rare offering that combines the timeless charm of a classic farmhouse with the comfort and efficiency of modern construction. Built in 2010 and set on over 5 picturesque acres surrounded by mature trees, this exceptional property offers a peaceful country setting just minutes from all the amenities of Fonthill. From the moment you arrive, the home's authentic farmhouse-inspired architecture, handsome brick exterior, and expansive front porch create a lasting impression. Thoughtfully designed and crafted using quality local materials, the home is rich in character while offering the conveniences expected by today's discerning buyer. At the heart of the home is a stunning custom kitchen featuring soaring 14-foot ceilings, exceptional millwork, and an inviting open-concept design that naturally draws family and friends together. The space is both grand and welcoming, perfectly suited for everyday living and entertaining alike. The main floor offers the convenience of a spacious primary bedroom, allowing for comfortable one-level living. Upstairs, two additional bedrooms are complemented by a versatile bonus room currently used as a sitting room/den, ideal as a home office, library, or potential fourth bedroom. A truly unique feature is the fully self-contained lower-level in-law suite with its own private entrance, providing outstanding flexibility for multi-generational living, extended family, guests, or income potential. Surrounded by nature and offering exceptional privacy, this beautiful property delivers the best of both worlds-tranquil country living with shops, restaurants, schools, golf, and everyday conveniences only minutes away. A distinctive home where craftsmanship, character, and lifestyle come together in a truly remarkable setting.
Property Type:
Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type:
Detached
Home Style:
2-Storey
Approx. Age:
6-15
Total Approx Floor Area:
3500-5000
Lot Size:
5-9.99
Lot Depth:
547'10¼"
Lot Frontage:
313'2"
Lot Shape:
Irregular
Topography:
Flat, Partially Cleared, Wooded/Treed
Direction Faces:
South
Bedrooms:
3+1
Bathrooms:
3.0
Water supply:
Well
Kitchens:
2
Kitchens in Basement:
1
Bedrooms Above Grade:
3
Bedrooms Below Grade:
1
Kitchens Above Grade:
1
Rooms Above Grade:
10
Rooms Below Grade:
6
Zoning:
NEC
Heating type:
Forced Air
Heating Fuel:
Propane
Fireplaces:
3
Foundation:
Poured Concrete
Roof:
Cedar
Basement:
Full, Separate Entrance, Apartment, Walk-Out
Fireplace Features:
Wood
Fireplace/Stove:
Yes
Garage:
None
Garage Spaces:
0.0
Other Structures:
Shed, Garden Shed
Parking Features:
Private
Parking Spaces:
0
Total Parking Spaces:
14.0
Family Room:
Yes
Possession Details:
TBD
Pool:
None
Link:
No
HST Applicable To Sale Price:
Included In
Assessment Year:
2026
Taxes:
$14,332 / 2026
Assessment:
$- / 2026
Niagara
Thorold
559 - Cataract Road
Wooded/Treed, Cul de Sac/Dead End
In-Law Suite, Water Softener, Water Purifier
Two Propane Tanks
Main floor: Refrigerator/Freezer, Stove, Dishwasher, Washer, Dryer
Lower Level: Refrigerator, Stove, Washer, Dryer
Brick Front
Trees/Woods
Floor
Type
Size
Other
Main
Kitchen
21' × 17'11¾"
Combined w/Dining, Combined w/Great Rm
Main
Living Room
27' × 13'11"
Main
Primary Bedroom
18'3" × 13'8"
Main
Laundry
8'8" × 7'1"
Second
Bedroom
14'6" × 9'7¾"
Second
Bedroom
14'6" × 10'11"
Second
Family Room
13'7¾" × 13'3½"
Lower
Kitchen
24'3¾" × 14'8¾"
Combined w/Living
Lower
Bedroom
14'9" × 14'6"
Lower
Recreation
24'10" × 19'8"
Lower
Laundry
10'7½" × 8'11"
Water Supply Types:
Drilled Well
Special Designation:
Unknown
Sewers:
Septic
Air Conditioning:
Central Air
Central Vacuum:
No
Seller Property Info Statement:
No
Laundry Level:
Main Level
Date Listed:
Jun 12, 2026
  • Photo 1: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 1 of 50
  • Photo 2: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 2 of 50
  • Photo 3: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 3 of 50
  • Photo 4: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 4 of 50
  • Photo 5: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 5 of 50
  • Photo 6: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 6 of 50
  • Photo 7: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 7 of 50
  • Photo 8: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 8 of 50
  • Photo 9: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 9 of 50
  • Photo 10: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 10 of 50
  • Photo 11: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 11 of 50
  • Photo 12: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 12 of 50
  • Photo 13: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 13 of 50
  • Photo 14: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 14 of 50
  • Photo 15: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 15 of 50
  • Photo 16: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Main floor Primary Bedroom
  • Photo 17: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Main floor Primary Bedroom
  • Photo 18: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Main floor Primary Bedroom
  • Photo 19: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 19 of 50
  • Photo 20: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 20 of 50
  • Photo 21: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Main floor laundary
  • Photo 22: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 22 of 50
  • Photo 23: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 23 of 50
  • Photo 24: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 24 of 50
  • Photo 25: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 25 of 50
  • Photo 26: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 26 of 50
  • Photo 27: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 27 of 50
  • Photo 28: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 28 of 50
  • Photo 29: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 29 of 50
  • Photo 30: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 30 of 50
  • Photo 31: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 31 of 50
  • Photo 32: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Separate Entrance to In-Law Suite
  • Photo 33: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    In-Law Suite Great Room
  • Photo 34: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 34 of 50
  • Photo 35: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 35 of 50
  • Photo 36: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 36 of 50
  • Photo 37: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    In-Law Suite Bedroom
  • Photo 38: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    In-Law Suite Bedroom
  • Photo 39: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    In-Law Suite Bedroom
  • Photo 40: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    In-Law Suite Laundry
  • Photo 41: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 41 of 50
  • Photo 42: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 42 of 50
  • Photo 43: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 43 of 50
  • Photo 44: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Side Entrance to Main Level
  • Photo 45: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 45 of 50
  • Photo 46: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 46 of 50
  • Photo 47: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 47 of 50
  • Photo 48: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 48 of 50
  • Photo 49: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 49 of 50
  • Photo 50: 2877 McSherry Lane in Thorold: 559 - Cataract Road House for sale : MLS®# X13438342
    Photo 50 of 50
Listed by SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY CANADA
Data was last updated June 15, 2026 at 02:15 PM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
165
Avg list price:
$739,000
Min list price:
$349,000
Max list price:
$4,999,999
Avg days on market:
47
Min days on market:
3
Max days on market:
700
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type and located in Thorold. Average values are derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by the MLS® system.
KAITLYNN MARTINS
This website may only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate of the type being offered via the website. The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of the PropTx MLS®. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate.